Your browser is not recommended for EDX, we suggest using the latest version of Google Chrome.

AN EVALUATION OF THE PERFORMANCE OF FIVE GAUSSIAN DISPERSION MODELS IN A COMPLEX TERRAIN ENVIRONMENT

License(s):

Other (Open)

"TRC Environmental Consultants, Inc; under contract to Occidental Oil Shale, Inc ., has conducted an evaluation of the performance of five Gaussian complex terrain models . The purpose of this effort is to satisfy a permit condition required by the Colorado Air Pollution Control Division to utilize meteorological and air quality data measured at Occidental's Logan Wash oil shale processing facility in a comparative assessment of model predictions . The five models tested were MPTER, COMPLEX I, COMPLEX II, COMPLEX I with modified terrain correction factors, and COMPLEX I employing an alternate plume height option. Both long-term (about 7 . 5 months) and short-term (hourly) average concentrations of hydrogen sulfide (H 2S) were computed by each of the models, the results from which were compared to actual measurements collected at Logan Wash during 1982 . Several statistical tests were utilized to facilitate the evaluation of the performance of these models. The results from these analyses indicate that these models are poor predictors of H 2 S concentrations at Logan Wash . The models demonstrated limited skill in predicting the magnitude, time, location, or frequency of peak pollutant impacts. This is not surprising because many of the assumptions that are implicit in these models are of questionable validity in complex terrain environments, so the results t hat they provide in such situations are , at best, of dubious value."

Followers: 0

Citation (Click to Copy)

Data and Resources

    Gathering Resources...

Keywords

Additional Info

Field Value
Last Updated September 29, 2016, 22:17 (LMT)
Created September 29, 2016, 22:17 (LMT)
Citation ROBERT J. KALEEL ---- Roy Long, AN EVALUATION OF THE PERFORMANCE OF FIVE GAUSSIAN DISPERSION MODELS IN A COMPLEX TERRAIN ENVIRONMENT, 2016-09-29, https://edx.netl.doe.gov/dataset/an-evaluation-of-the-performance-of-five-gaussian-dispersion-models-in-a-complex-terrain-environmen
Netl Product yes
Poc Email Roy.long@netl.doe.gov
Point Of Contact Roy Long
Program Or Project KMD
Publication Date 1984-3-12